The Scoop New York is a non-profit website and newsletter covering the movement for a true no-kill New York, from Buffalo to Brooklyn.
The Scoop New York is the only news outlet to consider newsworthy publicly-funded cruelty to homeless companion animals, as well as decades of officials’ deliberate abuse — psychological, financial and physical — of the New Yorkers who care for and about them.
Published by TSNY, NYC ACC KILLS enumerates and memorializes adoptable cats and dogs who were exterminated by Animal Care Centers of New York City.
Tax-deductible donations and paid subscriptions make it possible for The Scoop New York to investigate and expose kill-pound corruption statewide. Tap or click here to donate or subscribe. Thank you.
Headlines from Buffalo to Brooklyn
It’s September 13, 2026. This is The Weekly Poop.
This week, we’re examining the outcomes of three New York animal cruelty cases, with differing circumstances and jurisdictions, that were disposed in much the same way: a plea deal with a misdemeanor conviction — despite, in two examples, a felony top charge — and no intervention or community service component meant to help reduce the likelihood of re-offending.
While the cases were chosen at random, it’s apparent that, though district attorneys and SPCAs with enforcement powers have implored state lawmakers to make it easier to separate animal abusers from their victims, prosecutors often don’t use the tools they have.
Each defendant in the three sample cases was arrested in 2024 for offenses committed that year. All three cases were adjudicated in 2026. The adjournment hearing for one defendant, in Nassau County, appeared on Friday’s docket. Court proceedings for the other two cases, in Erie County and Manhattan, concluded earlier this year.
Though each perpetrator was determined to have caused pain, suffering and, in some instances, death to defenseless companion animals, and though two were charged with felony cruelty, none received jail time. Nor do court records indicate the defendants were compelled to participate in animal abuser rehabilitation programs in lieu of a prison sentence.
According to court records, none of the convicted abusers in these cases were permanently prohibited from possessing domesticated animals.
Erie County
Joshua Taylor, also known as Moriah Taylor, 39, was charged with felony aggravated cruelty for smothering two kittens to death with a pillowcase at Taylor’s apartment in Hamburg in January 2024.
Aggravated cruelty to animals is a class E felony, New York’s least severe felony category. Penalties for aggravated cruelty range from two years in prison to no penalty at all.
Ultimately, Erie County District Attorney Michael Keane allowed Taylor to plead to one count of misdemeanor cruelty. Taylor was sentenced to a 1-year conditional discharge, $250 in fees and court costs, and a 3-year ban on adopting or owning a domesticated animal. All of which combined is about as close to scot-free as you can get.
New York County (Manhattan)
Joseph Kauffmann, then 22, was arrested in Manhattan in April 2024, after he took his severely abused dog to the vet.
As AMNY reported:
[Kauffmann] allegedly hurled his 14-week-old Border Collie called Luca from his bed on March 27, 2024. That same day, he also reportedly burned the puppy in the bathtub with scalding water. The dog could not walk when Kauffmann brought him to BluePearl Pet Hospital.
Luca had two femur fractures, three rib fractures, and severe burns on his back, ear, forehead, eye, and muzzle …
Luca was reportedly treated at ASPCA Animal Hospital for nearly two months. The Scoop New York found no contemporary coverage of the case indicating what became of Luca afterward.
Like Taylor, Kauffmann was initially charged with felony cruelty. And as in Taylor’s case, the prosecutor — Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg this time — was satisfied with a misdemeanor cruelty plea.
Bragg’s deal got Kauffmann a 1-year conditional discharge, $250 in fees and court costs, and a 15-year animal ban.
Nassau County
Hoarding is one of the many harmful side effects of New York officials’ longstanding indifference toward homeless companion animals and refusal to acknowledge the government’s responsibility for them.
In October 2024, 76-year-old veterinarian Linda Pesek was arrested after authorities discovered 100 to 200 (accounts vary) animals, with many of them ill, in distress, or dead, at her home in Woodbury.
“Veterinarians take an oath to heal animals, not harm them,” John Di Leonardo, executive director of Humane Long Island, told Patch. “[H]owever, what we found inside Linda Pesek’s home was one of the most horrific cases of neglect I’ve ever encountered — nearly 100 animals trapped in filthy, toxic conditions, suffering from untreated infections, overgrown beaks, respiratory distress, and even confined alongside decomposing animals.”
Dennis Michael Lemke, Pesek’s attorney, said his client took in animals who were injured or otherwise needed care until she was “overwhelmed.”
Pesek pled guilty to one count of misdemeanor “overdriving, torturing and injuring animals,” and “failure to provide proper sustenance.” In March, Nassau County DA Anne Donnelly agreed to a sentence of 3-years’ probation, $250 in court costs and fees, and just under $5,000 in restitution to Nassau County SPCA. Pesek was prohibited from keeping animals for 10 years.
Albany
As The Scoop New York reported in August, years have passed since Albany lawmakers last adopted legislation to help companion animals in any significant way. For that matter, legislators have for years failed to help police and prosecutors prevent animal cruelty, just as they have decided against adopting bills meant to keep domestic abusers from terrorizing human victims by harming family pets.
State lawmakers killed no fewer than five such bills this year. Legislation to restore bail for felony aggravated animal cruelty, strengthen the aggravated animal cruelty statute, establish a civil process for law enforcement to remove animals from dangerous home environments, and more were left on the table in 2026.
It is common for legislators to neglect such bills for several years running. The question, as always, is how long New Yorkers will tolerate electeds who willfully refuse to enact or improve laws intended to protect companion animals, and officials who decline to vigorously enforce them.
Here’s the latest New York companion animal news:
You can love companion animals or you can love watching their adoptive families terrorized by the government, but not both.
For $13 million you too can buy the governor of a prominent northeastern state.
Zohran Mamdani, duplicitous hypocrite? Say it ain’t so.
The state Gaming Commission is chuffed that five horses were sacrificed for human amusement at Saratoga this summer.
NYC DOH is apparently covering NYC with a type of rat poison — deadly to wildlife as well as cats and dogs and children — that state legislators are trying (unsuccessfully, so far) to restrict to NYS-certified usage.
Good Samaritans saved Willie Bee from the Willy-B; now Willie Bee [260234] needs someone to save him from the NYC kill pound.
“Hoosick Falls breeder under investigation after puppies die from parvovirus”
A group of attention-starved men is selling puppy-milled dogs in NYC “in broad daylight” and NYPD is not on it.
Someone(s) is/are fatally poisoning stray cats and “other pets” in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn.
Twenty-one neglected dogs were seized from a Manorhaven storefront belonging to a woman who operates an apparently unregistered “rescue” and was recently arraigned in Pennsylvania for transporting scores of animals — one of whom died — in “inhumane conditions.”
Finally: Godspeed, Lloyd and Lexi.
From NYC ACC KILLS
Food recalls
FDA recently announced one pet food recall:
Fi supplements for dogs [salmonella]
Check here for more info on FDA-announced recalls, and here for details on prior FDA advisories and outbreaks.